UK consumers want human oversight as banks expand AI use
By Divya Shah
Key takeaways
- Only 13% of surveyed UK consumers support AI independently handling charge disputes, while most want human involvement.
- Consumers are more comfortable with AI managing routine account enquiries than sensitive financial interactions.
- The findings highlight the need for banks to balance AI-driven efficiency with human oversight and accountability.
Why this matters: The findings highlight the importance of responsible AI deployment in financial services, where automation must balance operational efficiency with customer trust, human judgement and accountability.
Artificial intelligence (AI) is becoming increasingly embedded in financial services customer operations, but UK consumers remain cautious about allowing the technology to handle sensitive financial matters without human involvement. New research from Five9 suggests that while customers recognise the benefits of AI in customer service, they continue to expect human judgement when dealing with disputes, refunds and other consequential interactions.
According to findings from Five9’s 2026 Consumer CX Report, only 13% of UK consumers who had recently contacted a financial services provider believe AI should independently handle charge disputes. The research surveyed 413 UK consumers who had contacted financial services customer service during the previous six months.
More than half (51%) said charge disputes should be managed entirely by a person. A further 37% would accept AI involvement, provided a human employee maintains direct oversight or approves the outcome. This indicates that consumers are more comfortable with AI supporting dispute resolution than taking full responsibility for decisions.
The preference for human involvement extends to other sensitive customer service activities. The research found that 91% of respondents believe high-stakes escalations should involve a human, including 63% who want these interactions handled entirely by a person. Meanwhile, 86% expect human involvement in refunds or financial adjustments, while 85% want a person involved in sensitive identity verification processes.
However, the findings do not suggest that consumers are opposed to AI adoption in financial services. In fact, those who had recently contacted a financial services provider were more likely to recognise its usefulness. Some 52% of this group considered AI useful for customer service, compared with 42% of respondents who had not recently contacted a provider.
Consumer acceptance also varies according to the complexity and sensitivity of the interaction. For routine enquiries, such as checking order or account status, 77% believe AI can play a role, including 35% who are comfortable with the technology handling these requests independently.
This suggests that customers are more willing to rely on automated support when the task is straightforward and does not require significant financial judgement.
The findings come as AI adoption continues to expand across the financial services industry. A joint survey by the Bank of England and the Financial Conduct Authority, published on 26 October 2026, found that 86% of responding financial services firms were already using AI.
For banks and other financial institutions, the research highlights the importance of distinguishing between automating routine customer service tasks and allowing AI to manage decisions that could have a direct financial impact on customers. While AI can help improve response times and handle high volumes of straightforward enquiries, disputes, refunds and identity-related matters require appropriate oversight and accountability.
Andy Dignan, President of Five9, said the key question for banks is not whether AI should be used in customer service, but where it should be allowed to operate independently.
He noted that customers may be comfortable with AI responding to routine account enquiries, but disputed transactions and sensitive financial issues require a different level of care. Financial institutions should therefore measure the success of AI beyond the number of interactions automated, using the technology to make routine services faster while keeping human judgement central to higher-stakes decisions.
Overall, the research points to a customer service model in which AI and human employees have complementary roles. For financial institutions, the challenge will be to identify which interactions can be automated safely and where human intervention remains essential to maintaining customer trust.
Previous Article
IBSi FinTech Journal

- Most trusted FinTech journal since 1991
- Digital monthly issue
- 60+ pages of research, analysis, interviews, opinions, and rankings
Other Related News
Related Reports
US FinTech Market Landscape & Vendor Analysis 2026
Know More
Global Digital Banking Market Landscape & Vendor Analysis Q2 2026
Know More
Wealth Management & Private Banking Systems Report Q4 2025
Know More
US FinTech Market Landscape & Vendor Analysis 2026
Know More


