Sales League Table 2020 | Banking Technology Winners

Results Announced!

IBS Intelligence launches BankTech Daily News

Subscribe today. Limited time offer.

The Black Swan Opportunity | Get your bank digital ready.

IBSI Special 5 Digital Report Package with Special Offer. Subscribe now

India FinTech Report 2020

Insights into the historical and projected market size of key FinTech categories. Subscribe now

UK crypto, smart contract statement ‘far from a done deal’

The UK’s legal statement on crypto assets and smart contracts provides market participants with a legal baseline on crypto but does little to kickstart the use of smart contracts, the industry has responded.

Juliet Mason, legal director at TLT

Juliet Mason, legal director at TLT

Yesterday, the UK Jurisdiction Taskforce of the LawTech Delivery Panel published a legal statement on crypto assets and smart contracts wherein the panel addressed the legal uncertainty associated with recognising crypto assets and smart contracts as a tradeable property and as enforceable agreements respectively.

Smart contracts aim to implement and automate performances of contracts between parties, automatically executing transactions by removing the middleman. However, the key hurdle for wider adoption of smart contracts is that they are in their infancy, Juliet Mason, legal director at UK law firm TLT, told IBS Intelligence.

“Smart contracts certainly have wide practical adoption possibilities – however, whether this includes wide application as fully independent contracts is far from a done deal.”

She noted that they also cannot yet be drafted to give the same commercial flexibility as a fully written agreement.

“For example, even the simplest of contracts will include exclusions of liability. How do you write an exclusion of indirect loss into a smart contract? Never mind indemnities or such phrases as ‘reasonable endeavours’ or ‘material breach’. The reason for these phrases in legal contracts is to give the parties flexibility as not all possible eventualities can be known at the outset.”

“Some may say that such flexibility is not required for smart contracts – however, there is no such thing as perfectly written code. There is always the risk of error and unforeseen events and, of course, the industry is still wrestling with the Oracle Problem. Therefore, smart contracts are often used to perform part of a wider traditional agreement (such as the payment mechanism) rather than representing an entire standalone legal contract,” Mason commented.

Tara Waters, FinTech partner at Ashurst

Tara Waters, FinTech partner at Ashurst

The statement does, however, provide more clarity for the UK market on the legal status of crypto assets, reiterating the need for a multi-faceted and fact-specific analysis, according to Tara Waters, a fintech partner at law firm Ashurst.

“By acknowledging that crypto assets should be treated in principle as property, it provides market participants with a legal baseline from which to conduct that analysis. The statement also identifies some areas where further clarification in law would be helpful – for example, in relation to transferability and registration of ownership of crypto assets.

“This further analysis and guidance will certainly be helpful for legal practitioners, although other market participants are likely to still feel uncertainty as to how their proposed activities fit within the wider and complex legal & regulatory environment,” Waters said.

Related IBS Intelligence Research

Related Posts


NAB to recruit bankers and advisers for high net wealth clients

National Australia Bank (NAB) announced that it will recruit 50 new bankers and advisers, as part of its new strategy to provide high net wealth clients with a single point of access for their financial needs, ranging from wealth creation, business growth to retirement needs and philanthropic investment. JBWere CEO and leader for NAB Private, […]

This post is only available to members.

Read More »

EQ launches new automated complaints management product

EQ has announced that it is launching a new automated complaints management product for the financial services industry, EQ Complaints Professional. The new solution is expected to enable firms to enforce their FCA compliance immediately as well as continually as regulation changes. Andrew Edler, MD of EQ Charter, commented, “We are delighted to bring this […]

This post is only available to members.

Read More »
bank, FinTech, neobank, smartbanks, challenger banks, Asia

Australia’s big 4 banks welcome the launch of open banking

The Competition and Consumer (Consumer Data Right) Rules went live on July 1, in Australia. This has been welcomed by the big 4 banks of the country – ANZ, Westpac, Commonwealth Bank and NAB where they will be sharing their customers’ data with third parties, when requested by the customer. Angus Sullivan, CBA’s Group Executive […]

This post is only available to members.

Read More »

Lendio facilitates $8 bn in PPP loans to 100,000 small businesses

Lendio, a leading marketplace for small business (SMB) loans, announced that the company has till now facilitated $8 B in Paycheck Protection Program (PPP) loans for 100,000 small businesses. The firm’s partnership with 300 SBA-approved financial institutions and FinTech leaders has helped the company to secure COVID-19 relief funds for several underserved segments of the […]

This post is only available to members.

Read More »